The view of its legitimacy is based on the authenticity of the hadith, and if (the hadith) is not affirmed, then it is not valid.вЂќ (al-Ikhtiyaaraat, pg. (In the latter case,) it is recommended to recite (Surah) Yaaseen. вЂњRecital (of Quran) over the deceased after their death is an innovation unlike its recital over the one expecting death. They would recite Surah Yaaseen to the one approaching death.ДЇourthly: If the Companions understood from the ProphetвЂ™s ШµЩ„Щ‰ Ш§Щ„Щ„Щ‡ Ш№Щ„ЩЉЩ‡ Щ€ШіЩ„Щ… statement, вЂRemind *your deceased* of the (testimony of faith) вЂLaвЂ™Ilaha ill-Allah.'вЂќ to mean at the grave, they would not disobeyed that command and it would have been a habitual famous practice among themвЂ¦вЂќ

Thirdly: This was the action and practice of the people qadeeman wa hadeethan (in the past and present). Certainly this chapter (Yaaseen) is the heart (essence) of the Quran) and its recital has an astonishing distinctive effect on the one expecting deathвЂ¦ вЂњFirstly: The one expecting death benefits from this chapter, due to its topics on Tawheed, the Hereafter, glad tidings of Paradise for the people of TawheedвЂ¦so the soul rejoices and as a result yearns/loves to meet Allah and Allah loves to meet (the soul). The first view is clearest from (a few) aspectsвЂ¦вЂќ Among the things he mentioned, It is also possible for the intent of the recital to be at the grave (once the person has died). Remind вЂyour deceasedвЂ™ (meaning, those on their death bed) of the (testimony of faith) вЂњLaвЂ™Ilaha ill-Allah.вЂќ (Muslim) In this case, it is similar to the hadith, He wrote, вЂњIt is possible that the HadithвЂ™s intent (recital of Surah Yaseen) is done to the one approaching death. After mentioning some narrations of the scholars in the past reciting Quran over the deceased, He relays the hadith about Yaaseen & its proper interpretation: Ibn al-Qayyim Ш±ШЩ…Щ‡ Ш§Щ„Щ„Щ‡ also affirmed that understanding in his book вЂњar-RoohвЂќ pgs. This intent is known based on the placement of his statement and further explained by Sh. His (and the MadhhabвЂ™s вЂ“ see ash-Sharh al-Kabeer w/ al-Insaaf 6/15) position is that it is recited BEFORE the person dies, not after. Musaa al-Hajjaawi Ш±ШЩ…Щ‡ Ш§Щ„Щ„Щ‡ (author of Zaad al-MustaqniвЂ™) did not state that it is permissible to recite Surah Yaseen over the dead. So it is first important to understand the intent of the FuqahaaвЂ™s statements before rushing to respond to them. I donвЂ™t think you intended this, but because of your comments (this one and the other about az-Zaad), others may mistakenly believe that the Hanaabilah believe it is permissible to recite Surah Yaaseen upon the dead. *N2: if the reader is unable to patiently read and understand these issues, then they should not engage in such discussions.* then please pardon me for my deficiency & lack of ability of correctly expressing myself.* If you see any harshness, belittlement, etc.

*Note 1: All of my comments here are written with love and with the purpose of understanding and searching for the truth.

Principle pertaining to commands found in weak ahadith. Is the hadith weak? If so, is it permissible to act upon it? & a response to the statement: вЂњif it is based off weak ahaadeeth then why even share it and praise it or teach it if it opposes (the Texts)вЂ¦?вЂќДЈ. Do the Hanaabilah believe that recital of Surah Yaaseen (or Quran) is done over the deceased?Дў. These discussions are important to clarify due to many misconceptions the Muslims have been taught in the past.Дue to the length of this post, I would like to first summarize my discussion points, then elaborate on them.ДЎ. Respected elder and friend, jazaakumullah khayran for your constant thought provoking posts.

I believe that the post is deleted now but here is my response: This was a response written to a brother on Facebook. Keys To Fiqh | T.me/K2Fiqh | #K2FiqhResponses2 To recite Surah Yaseen on the dead or not?

( Leave a comment ) To recite Surah Yaseen on the dead orВ not?.

Recite surah yasin